Some questions and answers about Black Flies in Maine

Quick jumps:  Questions and answers about black flies | Web links to black fly information | Black fly maps from prior weeks | Home 

When is "Black Fly Season"?
    There is actually no single, uniform "black fly season."  The maps in the Maine Nature News archive are based on scattered local observations. But, there is enough information there to draw some tentative general conclusions for some locations in Maine.

• 
  Do the black flies persist after July? What is the best time to camp and hike in Maine and avoid the flies?
      You have asked a very good question.  The season can begin no sooner that late April in Maine because the black fly larvae, which hatch in clear running streams, do not hatch until everything thaws and the water temperature has also risen a bit. The black fly season moves, in general, from South to North and simultaneously from the coastal plain to inland areas and from lowest elevations up to the highest. So there is no precise "end" to black fly season in Maine. However by mid-July in most places after the birds have start gobbling them up, and after the black fly adults have bred for the season and go into "dormancy", the numbers dwindle drastically almost everywhere. 
       Here are some more key pieces of information, as a further general answer to your question:

• Black flies breed in running water, unlike mosquitoes, which breed in still water. Because there are about forty species, not all flourish at the same time.
• Black flies can travel several miles from their breeding site, so those environmental rules cannot be counted on completely, as a means to avoid them.
• Strong breezes tend to disperse them, as they are a very small insect.
• I have found, and others confirm, that black flies are generally inactive until the air temperature has risen to at least 50 degrees F., even in black fly season.
• I have also found that they seem less numerous at higher altitudes, probably because of a combination of the above three factors: the lack of expansive breeding sites, cooler temperatures and the more consistent presence of breezes.
• "Black flies are strongly influenced by color -- they find dark hues more attractive than pale ones, and blue, purple, brown, and black more attractive than white or yellow. A light-colored shirt, therefore, is a much better choice of clothing than a dark blue one. It is a moot point, however, whether blue jeans might not be better than pale trousers: if they are carefully tucked in at the ankles and are without holes, jeans may help to attract the flies away from the head region.":  Courtesy Rocco Moschetti, IPM of Alaska. ¹
• "Black flies often swarm around a person's head because they are attracted to carbon dioxide in the breath. ... Bites are concentrated on exposed areas of skin, especially along the hairline, feet, ankles and arms." Courtesy Jeffrey Hahn, University of Minnesota Extension Service. ²
• "The bites can produce a variety of reactions ranging from little or no irritation to considerable irritation and swelling. Sensitivity varies from person to person." Courtesy Jeffrey Hahn, University of Minnesota Extension Service. ²
• In general, unlike mosquitoes, they will not come indoors, nor fly at night, nor penetrate most clothing.
• Local variation is the rule. Local people are usually the most helpful resource, as they observe these things very carefully.

                                  

• Head nets and body nets really work, if one takes care to leave no gaps where the netting meets the shoulders or the ankles. Head nets can be draped over the hat you usually wear, or a version with an internally attached cap can be purchased.  When used without a cap, care must be taken to leave a small space all around the head that the insect cannot penetrate.

• 
  I am interested in the Latin name of the Maine black fly and a graphic illustration of the critter.
      The black flies comprise the family Simuliidae, and that is probably the best collective Latin name to give for them as a group.  Many (but not all) are in the genus Simulium.  Around 40 species are common in Maine, with about 10 - 15 species flourishing at any one location during the course of the black fly season.   I would hesitate to name any one species as the "most common," but Simulium venustum and Simulium vittatum  are found almost everywhere in the state, in varying numbers.  For an illustration you could go to the this site from the government of Canada:  http://res2.agr.gc.ca/ecorc/diptera/bf11-dp11_e.htm
• 
  My wife calls a black fly a "MayFly." I always thought a mayfly was a long flying insect with a waggly tail ... that came out in "May."   The black fly comes out as early as April so I can't understand why she thinks it is a May fly. Could you help provide the answer as to whether or not a Black Fly is a May Fly?
      Black flies are generally 1/6" or less. There are many species in North America. They all breed in running water. The females bite to get a meal of blood. They are a nuisance to humans in Northern areas from approximately May through July. Adults may live several weeks. All are members of the family Simuliidae. A nickname for them is "buffalo gnats."  I have not heard of them being called mayflies.
      American mayflies range from 1/2" to about 1-1/2". There are about 550 species in North America. They breed in lakes, ponds, streams. They spend most of their lives in water as nymphs, a non-flying stage in their development. The adults emerge winged from April through October. They do not feed at all during their brief adulthood, and die after 1 or 2 days. All are members of order Ephemeroptera. I do not know of any nicknames for mayflies.
• 
  I'm trying to get hold of pest control operator (PCO's) or university/government experts who treat farm or indoor accounts that are bugged by this bug. Do you know of PCO's who treat hotels, resorts, lodges, factories, homes, barns, etc.? Or perhaps you can steer me towards a dos-and-don'ts-type check list for preventing, discouraging, or treating black flies? Are there PCO's who are involved on government committees for area-wide black fly control efforts?  Any help you can provide is appreciated.
      A few pieces of information bear on your question, at least as it applies to Maine:

• According to the Eastern Cereal and Oil Seed Research Centre (Ottawa, Canada)

"Unlike mosquitoes, black flies seldom attack indoors or even in in a vehicle; once they sense being trapped their attention seems permanently diverted to escape and they spend the rest of their lives crawling up the screen or window pane."
(Note:  For the context of this quote, please go to their web site.)

• Black flies breed in running water, unlike mosquitoes, which breed in stagnant water. Although there are some studies about black fly larva control, there are logistical and environmental concerns:

a)   Most public water supplies originate in streams and other running water bodies.
b)   Larvae locate in very localized clusters, in dispersed, inconspicuous locations, making pesticide application much less cost effective than for other insects.

• Black fly appearance is characterized by a succession of flourishings of as many as 20 or 30 species in a locality, each with their own breeding time and cycle (some twice a season) complicating the management of any attempted control measures.

• The Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station has five publications you may want to know about, and perhaps obtain via interlibrary loan through your library:

• Black flies in Maine: biology, damage and control. 1977. (Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Miscellaneous Report No. 188.
• The Black Flies of Maine. 1979. (Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Technical Bulletin No. 95)
• Experimental Stream Applications of B.T.I. for Human Nuisance Black Fly Management in a recreational area. 1988. (Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Technical Bulletin No. 133)
• Possible control of the Black Fly Simulium Penobscotensis by Temporary Habitat Alteration. 1979. (Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Miscellaneous Report No. 215.)
• Research on the Black Fly Problem in Maine, a Report to the 105th Maine Legislature. 1971. (Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Miscellaneous Report No. 131.)

• Most control has concentrated on personal measures, such as use of repellant, and timing activities to avoid the hours, dates, temperatures, or places of maximum appearance.

• 
  Could you please clear up a question that has been the subject of much discussion around our campfires? Does the Black fly pollinate the Blueberry?
      Three important things pertain to answering your question.

1. As you may know, the black flies we see at any given time may actually be of different species, each with its own habitat and hatching time -- at some times more than one species is prevalent in a locality at one time. A few species hatch more than one generation in a year. Only the females of the various black fly species feed on blood, and not all feed on humans. (Some swarm only, but without biting. Others are not attracted to humans at all.)
2. According to Jeffrey Grannet's Black Flies in Maine; biology, damage and control (Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Misc. Report 188. 1977): "Male black flies do not bite. Their only source of nutrition is plant nectar or sap."
3. A lot of the plant pollination in Maine is done by species other than honey bees, since these do not easily survive the Northern winters. (Wild bee species, wasps and even hummingbirds all contribute.) By deduction, since there are adult black flies present almost all during the non-winter months, and since some feed on plant nectar thus incidentally pollinating as they feed, and since blueberries are in flower during months when black flies are present, I would conclude that, yes, some pollination of blueberries (and other flowers) may occur by some of the black flies.

The following would seem to strengthen the case. Roger W. Crosskey The Natural History of Blackflies (Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, 1990) notes in the subchapter on "Feeding on Plants", subsection on "Attraction to Flowers,":

"Probably almost any flowering plant will at times attract some blackflies in its flowering season if it is nectar productive, even if certain species have favourite plants in different parts of their geographical range. ... in Canada, the blueberry plants Vaccinium angustifolium and Vaccinium myrtilloides are specially attractive."
(Note:  I believe the common wild blueberry in Maine is Vaccinium angustifolium, although there are several other species.).

More grist for the campfire stories, I guess!

For more information, consult the source cited above, or Buchmann, Stephen L. The forgotten pollinators (Washington, D.C.: Island Press, c1996) or go to the following Web site about black flies:  http://res2.agr.gc.ca/ecorc/diptera/bf11-dp11_e.htm

• 
  Why are they called black flies when bigger houseflies are also 'black'?
      Almost every animal and plant has a scientific name and a common name or names. The scientific name is universally used by scientists and students worldwide.  The common names are used in daily life and may vary from one place to another for the same animal or plant.  The group of true flies includes: house flies, deer flies, horse flies, black flies and many other species.  The scientific name that the insect family of all black flies share is Simuliidae.  However this insect has many common names such as:  black fly, blackfly, buffalo gnat, and reed smut.  In French-speaking Canada they are known as mouches noires, in Latin America as jejenes, and so forth.
      To the European explorers who first came to the Western Hemisphere black flies were almost unknown in their home countries. When they encountered them here they gave them various names, usually by comparing with insects already known.  According to Roger W. Crosskey's book The Natural History of Blackflies (Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, 1990) the name was first used in New England, by at least the late 1700's.  The earliest non-Native persons to encounter them were merely describing the "new" insects in terms of the known insect group "flies" and the fact that they are dark-colored and that they are a type of fly.   Thus the name "black fly" came into common use, as there was no commonly used alternative.
• 
  Q1:   What brand name bug repellant not only keeps black flies from biting but also from swarming around my head? I have used Amway D15 and it prevents them from biting, but they still swarm around my head causing great distraction.
  Q2:  Do you have any knowledge of Vitamin B injections as repellants?
      Here are some citations to articles that may help.  Ask for them at your local library.

• "Natural bug defense (Feature article under  "Body Language: Mind, body and spirit " Annette McGivney. Backpacker April 2001, pp.31-32.  Evaluates some not-DEET repellants.
• "Fresh Loot" Christopher Solomon, Jackson Lynch, Grant Davis  Outside April 2002, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p. 118.  Evaluates several outdoor recreation products, including Lemon Eucalyptus insect repellent from Repel.
• "For Fun and Comfort in the Field" Peter Warshall Whole Earth Spring 2001 Issue 104, p30.  Evaluates several hiking and camping products including: Repel Earth Essence Insect Repellent from Forestry Suppliers.
• Bug Off" National Wildlife June/July 2002, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p. 9.  Reports the use of organic materials as insect repellents, including a comparison of aromatic oil from catnip with the chemical used in most insect sprays; the need of testing the safety of the oil; and consideration of the potential use of black pepper. 
• "The buzz on bug repellents" Good Housekeeping August 2000, Vol. 231 Issue 2, p. 67. 
• "Which bug repellents really work?"  R. Winter.  Consumers Digest July/August 2000, Vol. 39 Issue 4, pp. 20-23.
• "Natural bug repellents, L. Goldstein.  Prevention  July, 2000 Vol. 52 Issue 7, p. 174
• "Keeping bugs at bay"  C. Hayhurst.  E:  the Environmental Magazine  July/August, 2000 Vol. 11 Issue 4, pp. 52-56.
• "Buzz off!" Consumer Reports, June 2000, Vol. 65 Issue 6, pp.14-17. The importance of choosing a good insect repellent. Contents of repellents that were evaluated included: plant oils, IR3535, Bayrepel, permethrin and N,N-diethyl-meta-toulamide, called DEET; Top rated repellents including Amway HourGuard12, now sold under the name 3M Ultrathon, and Off! Deep Woods for Sportsmen. 
• "Headnets for the sane"  Backpacker May 2000, Vol. 28 Issue 4, pp. 128
• "How to keep the bugs from biting" M. Abramovitz.  Current Health 2 April/May 2000, Vol. 26 Issue 8
• "The Battle of the bug" Backpacker April 1996, Vol. 24, pp. 68-70+
• "Bug off!"  Consumer Reports, July 1993, Vol. 58 Issue 7, pp. 451-454. Evaluates 21 insect repellents including:  N,N-diethyl-meta-toluamide (DEET).   Ratings for Ultra Muskol, Cutter Unscented Cream; Ticks Off!; Avon Skin-So-Soft; etc.  Also addresses DEET's downside.

• I've been looking for a place to buy old woodsman's fly dope.  But have had no luck.  Do you know if it still exists ? I used it as bug repellant, rust remover and all purpose lubricant in the past - sort of like WD-40 on steroids. 
      Just to clarify:  the product was first sold in 1937 as "Ole Time Woodsman's Liquid Fly Dope" and the name "Ole Time Woodsman's" was trademarked in 1964 by Osborn Sherer of Holden, Massachusetts. The trademark was evidently allowed to expire, but I had seen several recent reports of people still buying the product, which seemed to show it continued to be manufactured and/or supplies remained in a few stores until a few years ago. 
     Now Lexington Outdoors of Bangor, Maine has "brought back the original 1882 Ole Time Woodsman Fly Dope Formula... Contains no DEET."   The difference in origin dates seems to indicate a traditional formulation that predates Sherer's.  Or possibly they have resurrected Sherer's formula.
• 
  Q1:  Our son is real sensitive to any bug or mosquito bites.  What is the best form of prevention and the best form of relief post bite?
  Q2:  I was hiking on the Carter-Moriah Trail [New Hampshire], and something bit me behind my left ear although I didn't know it at the time. About three days later I had a sore throat and earache on the left side of my head and pain to-the-touch in the same general area up to the top of my head, as well as, about six bites and swelling behind my ear. I didn't suspect Black flies because there was none of the usual sensitivity, itching or welts common with the bites. I ended up going to the doctor. All is well now except for some slight stiffness and pain that seems to be receding quite rapidly each day.
  Q3:  When a human is bitten, and as I have seen the swelling and itching, is there potential for an infection specific to this gnat and to what degree does it occur? My wife and I have been going to the Adirondack Mountains for a number of years in the winter months but have always regarded the spring as off-limits due to my wife's sensitivities to bites. We recently spent a weekend at our house and of course she has sustained a bite on her head where her hair meets her forehead. There is an intense red circle about the size of a quarter at this site and a more diffuse swelling about 3 inches which is not discolored that extends across her forehead from hairline to eyes, with resulting headaches and eye sensitivity. 
      From time to time people write in to the Maine Nature News with questions similar to the above.  Many people spend time outdoors with no ill effects from biting insects.  But under some conditions, and with some individuals there can be unexpected reactions.  Generally black fly bites cause some itching and minor swelling from the first few bites of the season, following which an immunity develops, with subsequent reduced reactions.  Nonetheless, even individuals who have lived all their lives in black fly country and are exposed every season, can have greater effects if they get an unusually high number of bites on their first exposure of the season, or have some significant change in their physical condition or medical status. Therefore everyone should take this possibility into account as they do with all other outdoor risks, and take appropriate precautions.
      Please keep the following things in mind:  

1. Learn about the insects in the areas you visit. Your local library can help you.  Also, some links to informational web sites are listed below.
2. If you already know you have some sensitivities or allergies then you should talk to your doctor ahead of time and plan to take precautions when recreating in the outdoors, especially when you visit an unfamiliar location.
3. If you get a bite or sting make a positive identification of the insect or arachnid from which you received it.  Not all alleged black fly bites are really from black flies.  Get positive professional identification.
4. Get medical attention for any reaction that appears unusual or concerns you.  Be sure to let the doctor know positively what bit or stung you.

Some possible sources of information:

•  The Illustrated Encyclopedia contains information and pictures on various topics. One can search the encyclopedia alphabetically.  Avera Health Central Office,  Sioux Falls, South Dakota  (Benedictine and Presentation Sisters):
      Article on insect bites and stings
• Medical Management of Bites and Stings.  University of Arizona Cooperative Extension Service, Urban Integrated Pest Management Team:
• Illinois Department of Public Health Prevention & Control:  Biting Flies

• 
     I would like an opinion on what size of mesh screen one should look for  when buying a screen house to protect that from black flies? There are a lot of screen houses on the market, but not all will keep out black flies. 

   Screen houses are a nearly ideal compromise between the desire to sit in comfort and to be in the open air, without compromising the experience of the sights, smells and sounds of the Maine outdoors.
   The adults of black fly species worldwide vary from 1 to 5 mm. About the screen houses, I believe you are right. Many are manufactured with the idea of keeping mosquitoes out, a much larger insect (perhaps 10-15 mm). If a satisfactory model is not available you may want to consider overlaying some fiberglass screening of the proper dimension. One other thought. It is important to be sure of what insects you have in your area, as there may also be, for example, some midge species ("no-see-ums") that you may also want to keep out. They are 3 mm or less and that would require fine mesh. I believe screening is commonly available in .05" mesh (1.3 mm) and is available as small as .011" (approx. .3 mm) mesh. Some suppliers' Web pages include (see Disclaimer): 

Aubuchon Hardware -- window screening
Coleman -- screen tents

• A question from one of our customers led me to do online research about black flies, which lead me to [this page] ... where I found mention of many types of netting and other repellents... but no mention of BUZZ OFF Insect Shield Insect Repellent Apparel.

A recent innovation is apparel with an insect repellant -- permethrin -- manufactured into the fabric. Per our disclaimer I am not endorsing the concept nor any particular brand.  The players right now appear to be:  3M Clothing and Gear Insect Repellen; Buzz Off Insect Shield Insect Repellent Apparel (BUZZ OFF Insect Shield, LLC); and Perimeter Insect Guard Insect (PineBelt Processing, Inc.)  As far as I know, so only Buzz Off™ has actually implemented this idea yet by partnering with select clothing manufacturers.

• Are there any ways to kill black fly larva and "nip 'em in the bud" so to speak?

A recent newspaper article suggests a way.  I haven't tried it.

Two methods offered for killing black flies, mosquitoes
Portland Press Herald (Portland, Maine)
May 5, 2005. pg. G.1

Scarborough Community Services is selling dragonfly nymphs and mosquito dunks in an effort to control mosquitoes and prevent West Nile virus. Dragonfly nymphs eat mosquito larvae before the mosquitoes hatch, and do not sting or bite humans.

Mosquito dunks are doughnut-shaped tablets made with an organic ingredient that kills mosquitoes and black fly larvae. Dunks may be placed in standing water, and are effective for approximately 30 days. To order, call Scarborough Community Services at 730-4150.

Order deadline is noon May 13. Pickup is from 10 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. May 25 at Community Services, located on the third floor of the Scarborough Municipal Building, 259 Route 1.

Copyright 2005 Blethen Maine Newspapers Inc.
http://pressherald.mainetoday.com/home.shtml
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner.
Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.

Web links to black fly information

Black flies (Simuliidae) (Agriculture and Food Canada)

• General information on black fly habitat and life cycles, with a colored illustration. Details of species prevalence throughout Canada.  Emphasizes its notoriety as a biting insect.  "No other biting flies inspire such apprehension, particularly among visitors to Canada, as do black flies." The information on this site has a little more applicability to Maine than the Texas A&M site (linked below) since we share the same bioregion with Eastern Canada.
  http://res2.agr.gc.ca/ecorc/diptera/bf11-dp11_e.htm
• Illustration of the black fly life cycle:
      http://res2.agr.gc.ca/ecorc/diptera/blackfly-mo_noire_e.htm

Black Flies Or Buffalo Gnats (Family Simuliidae) (Texas A& M University, Texas Agricultural Extension Service)
    General information on black fly habitat and life cycles, with black and white line drawings.
http://entowww.tamu.edu/extension/bulletins/uc/uc-019.html

Simuliidae - Black Flies (University of Alberta, Department of Biological Sciences)
    Twenty-two images of black fly life stages and body parts, including color and black white photographs and drawings.
http://www.biology.ualberta.ca/old_site/craig.hp/simuliid/simul.hp

Family Simuliidae (Bishop Museum, Hawaii State Museum of Natural and Cultural History)
    This page is part of the Catalogue of the Fossil Flies of the World (Insecta:   Diptera). Even a quick reading of this site shows that black flies have been around for a long time!
http://www.bishopmuseum.org/bishop/ento/fossilcat/fosssimul.html

(Thanks to Jim Bird, Science and Engineering Center, Fogler Library, University of Maine for suggesting the last 3 sites)

Personal philosophy

    It is possible to make more of the "black fly season" than may be merited, and thus visitors may miss some of the most beautiful times in Maine. I enjoy hiking in just about every month of the year, and camp in spring, summer and fall. Black flies can be worked around at most times of the year. I say this even as one who dislikes using "fly dope" (bug repellent), and so I try to substitute caution and knowledge for big doses of that goo. Of course, I am not indiscriminate about my hiking locations, and I do try to avoid the peak weeks for any given location. With some care I find that one might enjoy the outdoors all year round in Maine, especially if one has at least some flexibility of location.

Feedback

 If you found these questions and answers useful, and/or have comments or suggestions, please e-mail me.

Thanks,
Frank Wihbey
Editor and Founder, Maine Nature News

Return to Maine Nature News home page